Should You Buy a Honda Civic Type R Over a BMW M235i Gran Coupe?


When the BMW M235i Gran Coupe first launched, I questioned who it was for. It was an okay automobile—it was fast sufficient, had a pleasant sufficient inside, and was the most affordable M Efficiency automobile within the lineup—nevertheless it by no means actually excelled at something. There have been additionally higher vehicles within the section, such because the Mercedes-AMG A35 and Volkswagen Golf R. Now, although, there’s a brand new automobile within the section which may simply fully eradicate any motive to purchase BMW’s most cost-effective efficiency sedan—the brand new 2023 Honda Civic Sort R.

After all, there might be BMW snobs that scoff on the thought of shopping for a Honda over a BMW. Nonetheless, the Civic Sort R is not any joke. Its 2.0-liter turbocharged engine makes 315 horsepower and 310 lb-ft of torque. Evaluate that to the BMW M235i, whose personal 2.0-liter turbo-four makes 302 horsepower and 332 lb-ft. The Bimmer is all-wheel drive, whereas the Honda is simply front-wheel drive. However the CTR has one large benefit over the Bimmer, a handbook transmission.

The M235i solely comes with an eight-speed Aisin computerized and it’s truly a extremely good gearbox. Shifts are fast, easy, and all the time whenever you need them. Nonetheless, it simply can’t examine to the engagement felt from a correct Honda handbook. Honda has been making one of the best manuals within the enterprise for many years and the CTR’s is meant to be one of the best of them. I haven’t pushed the brand new Civic Sort R simply but however I’m hoping to take action as quickly as completely doable, principally for that three-pedal gearbox.

On the subject of dealing with, evaluations are trickling out for the Honda Civic Sort R and stories are good. It’s stated to have nice steering, a implausible journey/dealing with steadiness that’s softer than its predecessor and all the higher for it, and a very good four-cylinder engine noise. It’s additionally a lot fast. Should you’ve ever pushed the M235i Gran Coupe, you’d realize it has none of these issues. It’s numb, remoted, and has probably the most artificial, inauthentic engine/exhaust noises within the business. It’s a complete snooze-fest.

The Honda Civic Sort R additionally appears to be like about 100 million instances higher. The brand new Civic lineup is good-looking, high to backside, however the Civic Sort R is flat-out superior. It has simply the correct amount of infantile enjoyable, whereas additionally nonetheless trying like a severe sports activities automobile. Its inside is nice trying, with a easy horizontal sprint structure, cool trying gauges, and among the best trying shifters within the recreation. Honda additionally all the time makes nice seats. The BMW M235i Gran Coupe is fairly tough trying on the surface, with a frumpy, uncommon design, however its cabin is sweet sufficient and it’s made very properly. If there’s one space the Bimmer nearly actually has an edge over the Honda, it’s inside construct high quality. However when it comes to design, the Honda trashes the M235i.

Now right here’s the kicker—value. The BMW M235i begins at $46,400, whereas the Honda Civic Sort R begins at $42,895. Now which may sound costly for a Civic however when you think about it packs the identical energy and efficiency ranges because the BMW (in addition to the Mercedes and Audi equivalents), whereas trying higher, having real motorsport chassis and suspension know-how, and a handbook gearbox, whereas being cheaper, the CTR is a no brainer. I’ll should drive the Honda to actually know if it’s higher however I’m having a extremely exhausting time making an attempt to make a case for the Bimmer.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here