Which BMW 5 Series is Better?


“What have they executed to it!?” was nearly definitely my first response to the E60 5 Sequence upon launch in July 2003, twenty wonderful years in the past. As we’ve simply been handled to a different controversial new BMW – and a 5 Sequence – we are able to look again on the 5 of three generations again. In fact, as “specialists” we knew the E60 could be a flop, ditto the E87 1 Sequence. However what do we all know? I first noticed the E60 5 Sequence by way of spy pictures and like many, I believed they had been computer-generated guesswork. No manner might BMW change the E39 with……that. However they did.

The E39 5 Sequence: A Properly-Beloved Automobile

It’s price speaking concerning the E39 briefly right here and the way it led to the E60 5 Sequence. Properly, it was a conventional BMW coming because it did after the very well-loved E34. The E39 BMW 520i was my go-to rental automotive in Germany between 2000 and 2003, some computerized, some handbook, at all times silver for put up Hertz resale worth and all with fabric trim and metal wheels. We used to joke about this – like Ford made the Hertz Mustang 350H, BMW had their 520i in a normal rental spec.

However what an excellent automotive it was. Certain, a BMW 525i could be higher, a 540i even higher, together with leather-based trim and the Harmon Kardon sound system. However in actuality, the automated BMW 520i was a wonderful day by day automotive and a tremendous place to be for that 300-mile continuous trek. Although it was the most cost effective BMW 5 Sequence it nonetheless regarded and felt like a high quality merchandise, an absolute, a bedrock.

The E60 5 Sequence: A Gross sales Success Regardless of Blended Critiques

However there was an issue. Gross sales determined to tackle a gradual puncture after round 1999, particularly in Germany. The E39 was a a lot nicer automotive than the bug-eyed W210 Mercedes-Benz E-Class or the Audi A6. Moreover, in lots of respects, the E39 5 Sequence had no actual competitors – some thought it the most effective all-round automotive on this planet and I’ve no argument with that. However hadn’t we seen all of it earlier than? The 1998 E46 BMW 3 Sequence was a mini-me model and upon 1996 launch many thought the E39 was a fatter, softened up model of the earlier E34.

The E60 5 Sequence: A Departure from the Conventional BMW Look

So, the E60 5 Sequence. Chris Bangle is usually blamed for the styling which after twenty years nonetheless seems as divisive because it at all times did and distinctly gawky in non M Sport guise. However dated? Not a little bit of it. Actually, it was the work of Davide Arcangeli – Bangle merely guided, inspired and authorised. These early base model vehicles with 16-inch wheels regarded ridiculous on the time. Moreover, they highlighted the plain slab sides, the just about Z3-esque entrance finish (evaluate the 2) and the again finish that regarded like an E39 after a stretch and tuck facelift. Worse was to return once you sat contained in the automotive. All these years of honing BMW facias and devices to logical perfection, all gone. Now you had iDrive, a giant slab of a splash prime, oddly angled window switches and a normal end not in contrast to one thing GM was making again then though undoubtedly stable and effectively constructed.

Is that this actually a BMW?

The E39: Is It Nonetheless a Good Automobile At this time?

Properly, 20 years later I’ve to say that they had been proper in spite of everything. E39 5 Sequence fashions are feted as fashionable classics however to me they’re simply the 5 Sequence earlier than the E60. They got here, they went and that was that. Very good vehicles and all that, however is ‘good’ what we wish? Add to these subjective intestine emotions the failings of the E39 in previous age – sill and jacking level rust, failed sprint pixels, ABS module failure, cooling system meltdowns, and so forth., and I’ll move, thanks. A handbook BMW 540i or the fantastic M5 are exceptions, however what number of of these are there? For me, E39 fashions are too needy in previous age and never thrilling sufficient to warrant fixing each different weekend.

The E60’s Design: Love It or Hate It?

Get previous the iDrive, and also you’ll discover a automotive that basically is particular. The entrance finish, together with the interior construction and body, is all aluminum. The suspension was all mainly E39 design however subtly revised, and finally, the steering field of the V8 E39 was changed by a rack and pinion. And with the E65 and E60, plus the Z4, BMW lastly conquered physique rust, and even now, you’ll wrestle to discover a 2003 E60 5 Sequence with something aside from minor neglect rust.

The E60 isn’t excellent, after all. It has its personal previous age dramas – V8 valve stem seals, Servotronic steering woes, and so forth. However when you change these horrid concrete run-flat tires with some correct boots, there isn’t any doubt that it’s a tremendous automotive to drive. As a lot as I favored the later F10 to take a look at, there’s little question in my thoughts that the E60 drives higher and is extra of a BMW.

The E60’s Legacy: What Will It Be Remembered For?

Twenty years in the past, BMW knew they needed to get away from the middle-aged govt picture that they had been progressively buying, sharpen their instruments, and decrease the common age of BMW possession. The 2001 E65 was the primary faltering step, however the E60 actually nailed it down. Did gross sales improve although? Properly, in a nine-year life (Tourings left the constructing in ’04), the E39 offered 1,488,038 items, and the E60 had offered 1,369,817 examples over seven years by the point the final Tourings had been in-built July 2010. Not a large distinction 12 months over 12 months, however sufficient to show a degree. The E60 additionally had a gradual begin as Ye Trustworthy BMW patrons of previous acquired to grips with it.

On July fifth this 12 months, you may both increase a glass to the E60 or give your E39 a understanding pat on the roof, relying in your perspective. Me? I’d simply go and purchase myself one other E60, however a post-’07 pre-facelift model, thanks.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here